×

Power and Prestige: Sexual Harassment by Department Chairs, Medical Directors, and Hospital Executives

Home /  Blog /  Power and Prestige: Sexual Harassment by Department Chairs, Medical Directors, and Hospital Executives
default-post1
Brooke Lum

When the Person in Charge Is the Problem

In healthcare, careers are built on the approval of a small number of powerful people. A department chair can decide who gets a faculty position. A medical director can shape schedules, credentials, and evaluations. A hospital executive can influence who is promoted, who receives research funding, and whose contract is renewed. For residents, nurses, physicians, researchers, and administrative staff, those decisions can define an entire career.

That concentration of power creates real risk. When a senior leader uses their position to make sexual advances, comment on a subordinate’s body, or pressure someone into a relationship, the person on the receiving end often feels they have nowhere to turn. The harasser may be well known, well liked, and seen as essential to the institution’s reputation or revenue.

This article looks at why harassment by healthcare executives can go unchecked, why California law does not excuse powerful or high-earning harassers, and how an employment attorney can hold healthcare facilities accountable. It is general information, not legal advice.

Why Healthcare Institutions Sometimes Protect Their Leaders

Hospitals, medical groups, and academic medical centers depend on their top performers. A department chair may bring in grants and recruit talent. A surgeon or medical director may be tied to a program’s prestige or to a major share of patient volume. When someone like that is accused of misconduct, leadership may be tempted to minimize the complaint, delay an investigation, or quietly move the person who complained instead of addressing the behavior.

Healthcare workplaces also have features that can make harassment harder to report:

  • Steep hierarchies. Residents, fellows, nurses, and junior staff are trained to defer to senior physicians and leaders.
  • Careers that depend on references. A single bad evaluation or withheld recommendation can follow a clinician for years.
  • Small professional worlds. In a specialty or region, everyone may know everyone, which makes people fear being labeled difficult.
  • Long, isolated shifts. Overnight calls, on-call rooms, and one-on-one research or procedure settings can give a harasser opportunity and privacy.
  • Informal power. Some leaders control opportunities through influence rather than formal titles, which can blur who is responsible for what.

None of these features make harassment acceptable. They do help explain why victims of physician supervisor harassment often wait to come forward, and why delayed reporting should not be held against them.

How Abuse of Authority Becomes Unlawful Harassment

When a senior leader ties career benefits to sexual attention, that can be quid pro quo harassment. Examples include a chair suggesting that a faculty appointment depends on spending time together after hours, or a medical director implying that a preferred schedule or a strong evaluation will follow if an employee accepts their advances. The pressure can be unlawful even if the employee refuses and the threatened consequence never happens.

Harassment can also create a hostile work environment. Repeated sexual comments during rounds, unwanted touching in a procedure room, sexual messages sent late at night, or open comments about a subordinate’s appearance can make the workplace hostile, especially when they come from someone the employee cannot avoid.

California Law Does Not Exempt High Earners or Top Titles

No title, salary, or reputation places a harasser above California law. Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA):

  • Employers are generally strictly liable for harassment by supervisors. When the harasser is a department chair, medical director, or executive with authority over the employee, the institution is generally responsible for that conduct.
  • Harassers can be personally liable. An individual who commits harassment can be held personally responsible, no matter how senior they are.
  • Employers must prevent harassment. A hospital or medical group that fails to take reasonable steps to prevent harassment, or ignores warning signs about a leader, can be liable for that failure.
  • Retaliation is prohibited. An institution cannot strip a complainant of privileges, research roles, schedules, or advancement because they reported a powerful leader.

FEHA’s harassment protections also reach beyond traditional employees in some situations, including certain unpaid interns, volunteers, and people providing services under a contract. That can matter in healthcare, where physicians, trainees, and researchers may have different kinds of relationships with the institution.

Evidence to Preserve When Reporting a Healthcare Leader

When the harasser holds significant power, documentation becomes even more important. Consider preserving:

  • Messages. Texts, emails, pages, and messages on hospital or personal platforms, kept in their original form.
  • A dated record of events. What was said or done, where, when, and who was nearby.
  • Career records. Evaluations, schedules, call assignments, credentialing decisions, and research or grant communications, especially any that changed after you rejected the leader or reported them.
  • Witness names. Colleagues who saw incidents or heard about them at the time.
  • Your report. A copy of any written complaint and any response from the institution.

Keep copies outside of employer-controlled email and devices when you can do so lawfully. Be careful not to take patient information or other confidential records, since that can create separate problems. An attorney can advise on what is appropriate to keep.

How an Employment Attorney Can Hold Healthcare Facilities Accountable

Taking on a powerful healthcare leader can feel impossible alone. An employment attorney can help level the field by:

  • Evaluating the claims. Counsel can assess whether the facts support quid pro quo harassment, hostile work environment, retaliation, failure to prevent harassment, or other claims.
  • Navigating complex structures. Healthcare employers often involve hospitals, medical groups, universities, and staffing companies. An attorney can identify which entities may be responsible.
  • Protecting your career. Counsel can push for interim measures, such as changes to reporting lines or schedules, that protect you without punishing you.
  • Pressing for a real investigation. An attorney can challenge an investigation that is slow, biased, or designed to protect the leader.
  • Pursuing remedies. Depending on the facts, claims may seek lost pay, lost career opportunities, emotional distress damages, and other relief.

Common Questions About Harassment by Healthcare Leaders

I am a resident or fellow. Does California law protect me? Residents and fellows are generally employees of the hospital, university, or program that pays them, and FEHA protects them from harassment and retaliation. Training programs can involve more than one institution, so an attorney can help identify who is responsible for your protection.

What if the harasser is a physician who is not technically my employer? In many hospitals, physicians are part of an independent medical group or hold staff privileges rather than being employees. That does not leave you unprotected. The facility that employs you still has a duty to take reasonable steps to stop harassment by people it allows into the workplace, including physicians, vendors, and contractors.

Will reporting a department chair end my career? That fear is common, and it is exactly what retaliation laws are designed to address. An institution cannot lawfully deny you advancement, research roles, privileges, or strong references because you reported harassment. If those things change after a report, that pattern can be powerful evidence.

Can I report to an outside body instead of my employer? Yes. Depending on the situation, options may include the California Civil Rights Department, the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and in some cases a professional licensing board. An attorney can help you decide which reports to make and in what order.

What if others have complained about the same leader before? Prior complaints can matter a great deal. They can show that the institution knew about a risk and failed to act. If you know of other people who had similar experiences, note their names, but let an attorney guide how and when to contact them.

Conclusion: Prestige Is Not a Shield

Healthcare leaders hold real power over the careers of the people who work under them. When that power is used to pressure, harass, or punish, California law allows employees to hold both the individual and the institution responsible. A strong reputation, a large salary, or an impressive title does not change the rules.

If you have experienced sexual harassment by a department chair, medical director, physician supervisor, or hospital executive, the attorneys at Makarem & Associates can review your situation and explain your options in a consultation.

This article provides general legal information and is not a substitute for advice about a specific situation. Laws and deadlines vary and can change.

Contact Us!

Call Us: 800-610-9646

Email Us: [email protected]

Empowering Voices Against Harassment.

Recent Posts

Categories

Archives

Speak Up. Stand Strong.

Ready to Discuss Your Situation?

If you are experiencing workplace sexual harassment or retaliation, our California attorneys can explain your rights, discuss your legal options, and help you determine what comes next.